Our store has been restocked! Free patch with orders of $30 or more (before shipping)

Library Comic is published two days a week, Monday and Wednesday. Book reviews Tuesday and Thursday.

We recommend you also read The Haunted Skull by Willow Payne and Gene’s friend’s Tim Allen Stories .

 

Graphic Novel Review: Young Hag And The Witches’ Quest by Isabel Greenberg

Young Hag And The Witches’ Quest by Isabel Greenberg. Amulet, 2024. 9781419765117. 272pp.

At one point, I loved nothing more than an Arthurian tale of knights and magic, but these days I find myself a bit bored with most. But I could not put Greenberg’s graphic novel down.

This tale opens with Young Hag coming of age and joining the coven that includes her mother, now called Nearly Wizend One, and her grandmother, Ancient Crone. But after a night of celebration, she is told the truth; they don’t make magic like she expects because the doors to Faerie are closed. She is told why via the story of Morgan le Fay, who was supposed to keep magic alive, but who stole Excalibur. The Ancient Crone then shows Young Hag the piece of Excalibur, which they are keeping safe until they find a way to return it to the lake and lift the curse that keeps magic from le Fay and Britain.

The story of returning magic to our world is what takes up the rest of the book. Along the way, there are retellings of classic moments of involving Arthur, his father, and a few of his knights, both in the past and the story’s present. It has a few twists and turns that shouldn’t be given away or even hinted at in a review.

Worth noting: I love Greenberg’s illustrations so much that I even love the two pages at the front of the book that introduce the characters inside. And of all characters that made me smile, Britomart and Faithful Steed are my favorites.

Review: Two Choose Your Own Adventures

The Cave Of Time (Choose Your Own Adventure) by Edward Packard, illustrated by Paul Granger. Chooseco, 2025. 9781933390796. 144pp.

You find the entrance to a cave while hiking in Snake Canyon. You venture inside for a moment, but then hurry out. No matter which page you turn to, you find yourself in a different time. Will you survive the things you encounter? Can you ever find your way back home?

I’m so happy Chooseco is publishing Retro Editions of Packard’s books. This was one of my favorites when I was a kid, along with his The Mystery of Chimney Rock and Who Killed Harlowe Thrombey, both of which will be republished soon, and both of which were also illustrated by Granger.

 

At The Mountains of Madness (Choose Your Own Adventure) by Jacopo Della Quercia, Illustrated by Hanna Krieger. Inspired by the work of HP Lovecraft. Chooseco, 2025. 9781937133009. 208pp.

You’re “a teenage counselor at a very strange summer camp — Miskatonic Summer Madness — all the way down in Antarctica.” The pay is unbelievably high, and you’re going to earn it (if you survive). Your time there may include not just polar night and freezing temperatures, but also death-defying rescue missions, weird specimens, odd campers, Old Ones, the Necronomicon, a mysterious mountain, an ancient hidden city, and an AI that may or may not be on your side.

Krieger’s illustrations and the horror elements make this more teen-friendly than many of the CYOA adventures I remember from the 1980s.

Screenshot
Screenshot

Novel Review: King of Ashes by S.A. Cosby

Roman’s father is in a coma after someone ran him off the road, and it’s clear from the recent vandalism of his father’s work vans that this is no accident, so Roman returns home for the first time in years. His sister, Neveah, is taking care of the family’s business, a crematorium, at the cost of having any kind of life. His brother Dante is hiding from reality in a fog of drugs and booze. It quickly becomes clear that part of what Dante is trying not to think about is the debt he owes the Black Baron Boys gang.

Roman needs to bail out his brother, keep their sister in the dark if possible, and make sure his family is safe. He brings to bear his skills at making money (both legal and illegal), but that’s not enough. Luckily Roman has a friend who specializes in violence and chaos, and who may be able to help him find a solution to the whole mess.

Throughout the novel, the question of what happened to the siblings’ mother decades ago, when she simply disappeared after work, hangs over all of them. Did their father kill her and then cremate her body, as many suspect? Or is she still out in the world somewhere, living a secret life?

Cosby is one of my favorite contemporary crime writers, and this is one of his best books.

Graphic Novel Review: Rigsby, WI: Foothold (Volume 1) by S.E. Case

Rigsby, WI: Foothold (Volume 1) by S.E. Case. Iron Circus Comics, 2025. 9781638991410. 120pp, Includes a few short bonus comics in the back. My favorite is the one titled “This Comic Is About Pooping”.

This webcomic is about the lives of four teens in a small city in Wisconsin in 2002. At its heart are Jeordie and Bethany (that’s them on the cover), their friends Erik and Anna, and the blind — the forested, dead-end where they go to smoke and get high. They’re worried about sex, relationships, where to get cigarettes, and homecoming. Beth is on the outs with her mom, living with her aunt, and stuck getting home-schooled. Anna is (minor spoiler) taking Beth to prom as friends. Erik wants to take the girl he’s obsessed with, Pam, but she doesn’t seem to respect his feelings much (if at all). Jeordie is about to celebrate his three-month anniversary with Jenna, and he’s got a proposal for what they should do to mark the occasion. (He’s also got an awesome little old dog, Lou.)

I have little in common with any of these teens, but I absolutely loved this graphic novel. This is one of those wondrous comics where everything works, including the fabric of everyone’s clothes.

Worth noting: One of my favorite sequences takes place after Bethany’s mom won’t take her word that she’s taken her meds, and makes her take them again. The aftermath is both hilarious and heartbreaking.

Volume 2 will be published next year. (The Kickstarter for it is ending in a few days!) But if you also can’t wait, the comics are still available (and updating twice weekly!) at rigsbywi.com

 

“New” website

Hey there! Let me know if you notice any weirdness, other than that giant title at the top of the page. We’ve just switched to a new set of fabulous plugins (Toocheke!) and the import seems to have gone off without a hitch — all comments, comics, and reviews are here. But please let me know if you see any weirdness over the next few weeks.

Update: I can see that the Character links under the comics aren’t working as expected, which is affecting links on the About page and Fiendsofthelibrary.com . Hoping to resolve that next soon.

11/3 Update: Character links are now working!

Graphic Novel Review: Seoul Before Sunrise by Samir Dahmani

Seoul Before Sunrise by Samir Dahmani. Life Drawn / Humanoids, 2024. Translated by Nanette McGuinness. 144pp. Seong-ji and her friend Ji-won get into different universities after taking South Korea’s entrance exams. Even before it happens, Seong-ji is nostalgic for high school and afraid they’ll lose their connection. Ji-won is just excited about the future. Then the story jumps ahead into their first year at university, when Ji-won hasn’t called or texted Seong-ji for some time. Seong-ji works nights at a convenience store where she thinks about Ji-won and also realizes that she can see clearly into people’s homes at night. And in one of those apartments, she sees a young woman who then comes into the store. She says people tell her things at night, that they’re “chattier than in the daytime.” She starts to stop in regularly. And then she asks Seong-ji to step away from the store for a bit, so she can show Seong-ji something. And that’s how they start to visit empty apartments together. It’s a quiet, dreamlike adventure in which they get to know each other, as well as people in the neighborhood. Seong-ji also comes to some realizations about herself. Dahmani really captures Seoul at night, the sense of almost supernatural weirdness that can come over you when the bright, busy city is so still and quiet that it seems like you’re the only person there. I love the transitional moment in Seong-ji’s life he captures, too, as well as the way he illustrates everything. His art is sublime.

Cartoon Collection Review: Love & Vermin: A Collection of Cartoons by The New Yorker’s Will McPhail

Love & Vermin: A Collection of Cartoons by The New Yorker’s Will McPhail. Mariner Books, 2022. 9780358346227. 240pp. A collection of cartoonist / graphic novelist McPhail’s. comics; most are one-panel, and most of which appeared originally in the New Yorker. Many feature rats and pigeons. McPhail excels at capturing performative moments and straight-up, wide-eyed madness. This is a work of genius, as was his graphic novel, In.

Graphic Novel Review: Fitting Indian by Jyoti Chand and Tara Anand

Fitting Indian by Jyoti Chand and Tara Anand. HarperAlley, 2025. 9780063237544. 288pp. Nitasha is under a lot of pressure from her parents to be the perfect student and daughter, though she quietly rebels against those expectations. The fact that her brother is a doctor and also engaged to a lawyer only adds to her stress , though her brother treats her well. She also has her friends Ava and Nick, too, though maybe Nick wants to be more than friends. Nitasha’s life implodes in ways that involve social media, alcohol, depression, and self-harm. There’s a trigger warning about most of the above on the first page, as well as a list of resources in the back for teens and others dealing with these issues. Nitasha is such a well-rounded character, as are her friends, brother, and most of the rest of her family, that this isn’t some After School Special. Rooting for her and her loved ones pulled me through this graphic novel.

Book Review: Shroud by Adrian Tchaikovsky

Shroud by Adrian Tchaikovsky. Orbit, 2025. 9780316579025. 464pp. This is my favorite first contact novel. It’s set in a post-Earth interstellar future where humans function as assets for expansion across the galaxy. A ship has arrived at an unexplored star system to start exploiting local assets in order to create a waystation for humanity. The most notable body in the system is a large moon. It’s a dark, inhospitable place where light has never reached the surface (if it has one). But it is alive with a cacophony of radio signals. Scientists began studying and, via drones, exploring the moon. They discover life there. And as they begin to plan to send humans to the surface to try to make sense of what their cameras are seeing, the novel turns into a tale of survival, as well as one of trying to recognize a truly alien intelligence. (The book is told from both alien and human points-of-view). Worth noting: one of the characters in this novel has a role on their ship that’s unique among all of the futuristic jobs I’ve read about. I don’t want to spoil anything about the story, but this character and the way they help things work is amazing.

Graphic Novel Review: Zeroed Out: A Sci-Fi Rom-Com by Jim Munroe and Eric Kim

Zeroed Out: A Sci-Fi Rom-Com by Jim Munroe and Eric Kim (artist). At Bay Press, 2025. 9781998779673. 163pp. Offworlders and their tech have improved life for most folks on Earth. But Matias lost a girlfriend to one of the shapeshifting offworlders. Now he has a job working for them that’s so boring that all he can think about is how lonely he is. (He spends all day overwriting hard drives with zeroes.) But things start to change after his offworlder boss, Sam, introduces himself. At work, Sam looks like a neanderthal, and finds it refreshing how honestly Matias talks to him. Sam offers Matias overtime as an advisor, and Matias accepts. Matias soon finds out that on weekends Sam chooses to appear as an incredibly attractive young woman, and that Sam is lonely, too. The whole story is super weird, a not-quite-romance that goes in unexpected directions and which I thoroughly enjoyed. Between this graphic novel and Munroe’s prose novel We Are Raccoons I’ve become a fan, and plan to continue seeking out his work in books and other media.
Screenshot
Screenshot